The Reeb quotient of the thickening addition map
Setting
This digest continues reeb-geometric-thickening-addition.md and uses its objects without
redefinition. For ε : ℝ≥0, Band ε = [-ε, ε], the thickening of (X, f) is X × Band ε with
height height f ε (x, t) = f x + t, and functor ε is the thickening on the real slice
Over (TopCat.of ℝ). The addition map
addMap X ε δ : C((X × Band δ) × Band ε, X × Band (ε + δ)), ((x, s), t) ↦ (x, s + t)
has the outer parameter first and is not a homeomorphism; on the one-point space no slice
isomorphism T_1 T_1 P ≅ T_(1+1) P exists (not_iso_one_one). The Reeb quotient ℛ is that of
reeb-quotient.md, with its functoriality ReebQuotient.map and the slice functor
ReebQuotient.quotientFunctor ℝ of reeb-quotient-comparison.md. Geometric smoothing
geometricSmoothing ε = U_ε = ℛ T_ε on graph objects is that of reeb-rgraph-smoothing.md.
This digest shows that μ becomes an isomorphism after the Reeb quotient, for every space and
every height function, and packages the result on the real slice and on graph objects.
The section and the fibre paths
Write c = projIcc (-δ) δ u for the projection of u ∈ Band (ε + δ) onto [-δ, δ]. Then
u - c ∈ Band ε (sub_projIcc_mem_band), since |u| ≤ ε + δ. The section
addSection X ε δ : C(X × Band (ε + δ), (X × Band δ) × Band ε), (x, u) ↦ ((x, c), u - c)
is continuous because the projection onto a closed interval is. It preserves height,
f x + c + (u - c) = f x + u (height_addSection), it is natural in every continuous map
(addSection_natural), and μ ∘ σ = id (addMap_comp_addSection).
For z = ((x, s), t) put u = s + t. The straight segment from (s, t) to (c, u - c) keeps x.
It stays in Band δ × Band ε because both bands are convex and both endpoints lie in them, and it
keeps the sum s + t at every time. So addFiberPath z is a path from z to σ (μ z) inside one
height fibre of T_ε T_δ X (height_addFiberPath), and z is Reeb-equivalent to σ (μ z)
(reebRel_addSection_addMap).
The homeomorphism
quotientAddHomeomorph f ε δ :
ReebQuotient (height (height f δ) ε) ≃ₜ ReebQuotient (height f (ε + δ))
has forward map ℛ μ = ReebQuotient.map (addMap X ε δ) _ and inverse
ℛ σ = ReebQuotient.map (addSection X ε δ) _. On classes, [z] ↦ [μ z] and [w] ↦ [σ w]
(quotientAddHomeomorph_mk, quotientAddHomeomorph_symm_mk). The composite ℛ μ ∘ ℛ σ is the
identity because μ ∘ σ = id, and ℛ σ ∘ ℛ μ is the identity because σ (μ z) and z are joined
by the fibre path. Both maps are continuous because ℛ is a functor on continuous
height-preserving maps. The homeomorphism preserves height (height_quotientAddHomeomorph).
No compactness, Hausdorff or constructibility hypothesis is used, and the carrier universe of X
is arbitrary. The continuity of the inverse comes from the continuous section σ, not from a
compact-to-Hausdorff argument.
Two consequences are stated separately: ℛ μ is bijective (bijective_quotientMap_addMap), and
[μ z] = [μ z'] holds exactly when z and z' are Reeb-equivalent in T_ε T_δ X
(mk_addMap_eq_mk_addMap_iff). The second is the fibre comparison: the classes of T_ε T_δ X in
one height fibre correspond to the classes of T_(ε+δ) X in the same fibre.
The real slice and coherence
On Over (TopCat.of ℝ), ℛ μ is an isomorphism at every object
(isIso_quotientFunctor_map_addNatTrans_app), since its underlying map is the homeomorphism above.
Hence
reebAddIso ε δ : (functor δ ⋙ functor ε) ⋙ ℛ ≅ functor (ε + δ) ⋙ ℛ
with hom whiskerRight (addNatTrans ε δ) ℛ (reebAddIso_hom) and inverse components
ReebQuotient.map (addSection A.left ε δ) _ (reebAddIso_inv_app_left_hom). Naturality in every
slice morphism is part of the natural isomorphism.
Parameter equalities are bridged by bandEqIso h : functor ε ≅ functor δ for h : ε = δ, whose hom
and inverse are the band inclusions in both directions, never eqToIso or a cast on Band. The lax
laws of addNatTrans from reeb-geometric-thickening-addition.md pass through ℛ:
- Associativity,
whiskerLeft (functor γ) (reebAddIso ε δ).hom ≫ (reebAddIso (ε + δ) γ).hom ≫ whiskerRight (bandEqIso _).hom ℛ = whiskerRight (whiskerRight (addNatTrans δ γ) (functor ε)) ℛ ≫ (reebAddIso ε (δ + γ)).hom(reebAddIso_assoc). Since every other factor is an isomorphism,ℛ (T_ε μ_(δ,γ))is one (isIso_whiskerRight_whiskerRight_addNatTrans), and the equation holds as an equation of isomorphisms withreebAddInnerIso ε δ γ(reebAddIso_assoc_iso). - Units against
zeroIso, as equations of isomorphisms:reebAddIso 0 δfollowed bybandEqIso (zero_add δ)isℛofzeroIsoon the inner factor, andreebAddIso δ 0followed bybandEqIso (add_zero δ)isℛ T_δofzeroIso(reebAddIso_zero_left,reebAddIso_zero_right). - Zero sections.
ℛof the outer zero section followed byℛ μisℛof the enlargementδ ≤ ε + δ, andℛ T_εof the inner zero section followed byℛ μisℛof the enlargementε ≤ ε + δ(whiskerLeft_zeroSectionNatTrans_comp_reebAddIso,whiskerRight_zeroSectionNatTrans_comp_reebAddIso). - Band enlargement in both parameters (
reebAddIso_comp_bandInclusionNatTrans).
Each law is the ℛ-image of the corresponding equation of addNatTrans, checked on representatives
of the Reeb classes. The slice packaging is in universe 0.
Graph objects
For a graph object A, the Reeb quotient of T_ε T_δ A is a graph object
(RGraph.isRGraph_quotient_thickening_thickening). The witness is the Reeb quotient of
T_(ε+δ) A, a graph object because T_(ε+δ) A is a constructible ℝ-space, transported along
reebAddIso ε δ. The double thickening T_ε T_δ A itself is not claimed to be constructible.
RGraph.doubleThickeningQuotient ε δ : RGraphCat ⥤ RGraphCat is A ↦ ℛ T_ε T_δ A, literally
IsRGraph.ι ⋙ functor δ ⋙ functor ε ⋙ ℛ under the graph inclusion
(doubleThickeningQuotient_comp_ι, by rfl). The natural isomorphism
RGraph.geometricSmoothingAddIso ε δ : doubleThickeningQuotient ε δ ≅ geometricSmoothing (ε + δ)
has target the merged geometric smoothing and components ℛ μ
(geometricSmoothingAddIso_hom_app_hom, by rfl). It is the form in which a semigroup law for
geometric smoothing would consume the addition map.
Fixtures
TDA.Reeb.QuotientThickeningAdditionExamples:
- One point.
ℛ T_1 T_1 P ≅ ℛ T_(1+1) Pholds next to the mergedT_1 T_1 P ≇ T_(1+1) P. The height-0segments ↦ ((*, s), -s)collapses to one class, proved along the segment and again by injectivity of the homeomorphism from the common image[(*, 0)]. The height-0fibre ofℛ T_1 T_1 Pis a subsingleton, transported from that ofT_(1+1) P. - Boundary control. At
ε = 0on the point, the left unit law sends[(*, s), 0]to[(*, s)], and the section keepsuin the inner band and0in the outer band. - One edge. At
ε = δ = 1/4, the class of((q, 1/4), 1/4)withqat height1/2goes to the class of(q, 1/2), and the inverse returns it, the clamp of1/2being1/4. The identification[(q, 1/4), -1/4] = [(q, 0), 0]comes from the fibre path. Associativity at[((q, 1/4), 1/4), 1/4]gives the class with band coordinate3/4on both sides. - Two merging edges. On the parallel edges, the classes of the points over the two edges at
thickened height
1/2are equal inℛ T_(1/4) T_(1/4)although the points differ: their images lie in a subsingleton fibre ofU_(1/4 + 1/4). At1/8 + 1/8the height-1/2fibre ofℛ T_(1/8) T_(1/8)is not a subsingleton, transported fromU_(1/4). This places the thresholdε + δ ≥ 1/2of the single-parameter statement on the double thickening. - Naturality. The edge-swap square of
geometricSmoothingAddIso (1/4) (1/4)sends the class of the point over edgetrueto the class of the point over edgefalse. - Packaging.
ℛ T_(1/4) T_(1/4)of the parallel edges is a graph object, with its explicit isomorphism toU_(1/4 + 1/4)inRGraphCat.
Source correspondence
de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §2.4 Proposition 2.10 is the Reeb
functor, merged as quotientFunctor. §4.3 Definition 4.22 is the thickening, and §4.4
Definition 4.30 is the Reeb smoothing U_ε = ℛ T_ε, merged as geometricSmoothing. §4.4
Observation 4.33 asserts semigroup isomorphisms U_(ε₁+ε₂) ≃ U_(ε₁) U_(ε₂); this digest
prepares them, and they are proved independently in
reeb-quotient-thickening-absorption.md.
The section σ, the fibre paths, the homeomorphism ℛ T_ε T_δ ≅ ℛ T_(ε+δ), its coherence and the
graph-level isomorphism are library statements; none is attributed to the source.
Not claimed here: the absorption ℛ T_ε ℛ ≅ ℛ T_ε, the semigroup isomorphisms
U_ε U_δ ≅ U_(ε+δ) of Observation 4.33 and any statement about geometricSmoothing δ ⋙
geometricSmoothing ε, which are in
reeb-quotient-thickening-absorption.md; the geometric interleavings of Definition 4.36 and any distance inequality;
constructibility of T_ε T_δ A.
Source: de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §4.4, Definition 4.30 and Observation 4.33.