Thickenings of constructible ℝ-spaces: shared tools
Setting
A cylinder presentation P : CylinderPresentation n with levels S : CriticalValues n has vertex
pieces V i, edge pieces E e and continuous endpoint maps; its realization X = P.Realization S
is the quotient of (Σ i, V i) ⊕ (Σ e, E e × [a e, a (e+1)]) by the two endpoint identifications
per edge (see reeb-constructible-space.md). The thickening is X × Band ε with
Band ε = [-ε, ε] and height f x + t (see reeb-geometric-thickening.md).
The pieces are arbitrary topological spaces. Nothing below assumes that a piece, the realization or the thickening is Hausdorff, compact or locally path-connected. This note records the shared point-set tools and the morphisms of presentations used to describe the thickening of such a realization; no statement of the source is claimed by them alone.
Point-set tools
TDA.Topology.QuotientProduct proves two product facts for quotient maps.
- Locally compact factor. For a quotient map
q : A → Band a locally compact spaceI, the mapsq × id_Iandid_I × qare quotient maps (isQuotientMap_prodMap_id_left,isQuotientMap_prodMap_id_right). There is no separation hypothesis onAorB. The proof identifies open sets with continuous maps to the Sierpiński space and uses the exponential law for the locally compact factor (mathlib'sIsQuotientMap.continuous_lift_prod_left). Compact real intervals[a, b], including empty and one-point intervals, are the case used (isQuotientMap_prodMap_id_Icc). - Proper factor. A proper surjection
fstays a quotient map after product with the identity of an arbitrary spaceE(isQuotientMap_prodMap_id_of_isProperMap):id_E × fis proper, hence closed, continuous and surjective. A continuous surjection from a compact space onto a Hausdorff space is proper, so the same holds for it withEarbitrary (isQuotientMap_prodMap_id_of_compactSpace). Only the source and the target offcarry these hypotheses. This is the form intended for the scalar polygon and gluing maps of a thickened cylinder, which go between compact subsets ofℝorℝ × ℝ. Product stability is not claimed for arbitrary quotient maps; it fails in general.
Fixtures (TDA.Topology.QuotientProductExamples): the sign map x ↦ 0 < x from ℝ onto the
Sierpiński space is a quotient map onto a non-Hausdorff space, and its product with [0, 1] is a
quotient map onto the non-Hausdorff space Prop × [0, 1]; the map (s, u) ↦ (s u, u) from the
square onto the triangle 0 ≤ x ≤ u ≤ 1 collapses the edge u = 0 to a corner and stays a
quotient map after product with any space.
Presentation morphisms
TDA.Reeb.ConstructibleHom defines morphisms of presentations over the same number of levels.
CylinderPresentation.Hom P Qconsists of continuous mapsV i → V' iandE e → E' ewithleft' ∘ edge e = vertex e.castSucc ∘ leftandright' ∘ edge e = vertex e.succ ∘ right. Identity, composition and their laws hold componentwise.- On a fixed level list
S,Hom.realizeis the continuous map of realizations that is the vertex map on vertex points andedge e × idon cylinder points (realize_ofVertex,realize_ofCylinder,realize_ofStrip). It is the descent ofHom.compatibleMapsthrough the universal propertylift, preserves height (height_realize) and is functorial (realize_id,realize_comp). In universe0,Hom.toOverHomis the corresponding morphism of the real slice, with identity and composition laws. - A map of finite data is a morphism of the discrete presentations
(
FiniteReebData.Hom.toPresentationHom), and its realization isrealizeHom(realize_toPresentationHom).
Such morphisms keep the grid and the cylinder parameter: a height-preserving map of realizations that moves cylinder points along the parameter, or changes the level list, is in general not a realized morphism.
Thickened raw pieces
For every locally compact I, quotMk × id_I : Raw × I → X × I is a quotient map
(isQuotientMap_prodMap_quotMk), and two raw pairs have the same image exactly when their normal
forms and their second coordinates agree (prodMap_quotMk_eq_iff). For I = Band ε
(isQuotientMap_rawBandMap), X × Band ε is the quotient of the thickened raw pieces
Σ V i × Band ε ⊕ Σ E e × [a e, a (e+1)] × Band ε by the endpoint identifications, each times the
identity of the band. A continuous map out of X × Band ε is therefore the same as a family of
continuous maps on the thickened vertex pieces and cylinders satisfying the two endpoint equations.
This replaces a general statement that realization commutes with colimits of attachment diagrams:
the diagrams used for the thickening are over one fixed grid, their maps are presentation
morphisms, and their colimit is described by this quotient together with lift and hom_ext.
No theorem about arbitrary colimits of constructible spaces, and no general restriction of
quotient maps to subsets, is claimed.
Fixtures (TDA.Reeb.ConstructibleHomExamples): the collapse of two disjoint segments onto two
parallel edges between single vertices identifies the two vertex points at level 0 and keeps
regular points apart; a presentation whose pieces are the Sierpiński space, with non-Hausdorff
realization, admits morphisms from discrete segments and onto a single segment, and its thickened
raw pieces present its thickening; the presentation with empty pieces maps uniquely to every
presentation.
One cylinder
TDA.Reeb.ThickeningSlice and TDA.Reeb.ThickeningCylinder present the thickening of one
cylinder E × [a, d], for a ≤ d, ε ≥ 0 and an arbitrary topological space E. The thickened
space is E × [a, d] × [-ε, ε] with height s + t (cylinderHeight); it is the geometric
thickening of E × [a, d] with the segment coordinate as height, after reassociating the product
(cylinderHeight_eq).
- Slices. Under
(s, t) ↦ (s, u = s + t)the thickened segment becomes the parallelogram{(s, u) | s ∈ J(u)}withJ(u) = [max a (u - ε), min d (u + ε)], possibly empty or a point. Whena(ord) lies inJ(u)it is the lower (or upper) end. Between grid levels the ends move affinely; the transferfragAfffrom the slice atcto the slice atufixes a parameter at a segment end (SliceTransfer.fragAff_eq_left,fragAff_eq_right), and with transfer hypotheses in both directions the transfers are mutually inverse, with no nondegeneracy assumption (SliceTransfer.fragAff_fragAff). For a point slice the denominator offragAffis0, Lean's division returns0, and the transfer is the constant lower end. - Presentation. On any grid
Glisting the four eventsa ± ε,d ± ε,cylinderThickhas vertex pieceE × J(b j), edge pieceE × J(mid k)and endpoint maps the transfers to the slab ends. The endpoint maps collapse the reference slice at an end with a point slice; no inverse is asked of them. Pieces are empty where the slice is, and compact and locally path-connected whenEis. The vertex strip isa = d;ε = 0is not treated separately. - Homeomorphism.
toCylindersends(y, σ)at levelb jto(y, σ, b j - σ)and((y, σ), u)to(y, s, u - s),s = fragAff (mid k) u σ, and preserves height. The inverse is built in parallelogram coordinates on the finite closed cover by level slices and slab polygons. On a level slice it is the vertex inclusion. On a slab polygon it is the cylinder map descended alongid_E × polygonMap k, which is a quotient map for everyEbecause the scalar polygon map(σ, u) ↦ (fragAff (mid k) u σ, u)is a continuous surjection from a compact space onto a subset ofℝ × ℝ, hence proper. The cylinder map is constant on its fibres: inside the slab the transfer is injective, and at a collapsing end the realization identifies the cylinder end with its vertex image. Both inverse laws hold, socylinderThickHomeomorphis a height-preserving homeomorphism for every topologicalE, with no Hausdorff or compactness hypothesis;vertexStripHomeomorphis the vertex stripE × [-ε, ε]with heighta + t. - Boundary strips. On a common grid listing the events of
[a, d],[a, a]and[d, d],botInclandtopInclare presentation morphisms from the strip presentations into the cylinder presentation, andmapSpace fis the morphismf × idfor a continuousf : E → E'. The homeomorphisms turn them into(y, t) ↦ (y, a, t),(y, t) ↦ (y, d, t)andf × id. For an endpoint mapf : E → V, the bottom strip inclusion andmapSpace finto the vertex strip ofVare therefore described by the pair of identitiescylinderThickHomeomorph_realize_botInclandvertexStripHomeomorph_realize_mapSpace, andbotIncl_comp_mapSpacerecords their compatibility withmapSpaceat the level of presentation morphisms. - The grid of one segment. For
a < d,pairThickis the construction on the shifted witness of the two-level gridpair a d, whose levels are exactly the distinct values amonga ± ε,d ± ε, withpairThickHomeomorphand the strip inclusionspairBotIncl,pairTopIncl.
Global assembly of a whole presentation and the constructibility of its thickening are not part of these modules.
Fixtures (TDA.Reeb.ThickeningSliceExamples, TDA.Reeb.ThickeningCylinderExamples): point slices
and constant transfers at ε = 0; a vertex strip; coincident events d - ε = a + ε; a slab
meeting [a - ε, d + ε] in a corner only, with empty polygon, empty edge piece and a point vertex
piece at the corner; a non-injective collapsing endpoint map; and the Sierpiński space E = Prop,
whose pieces and realization are not Hausdorff while the homeomorphism applies.
Windows and transfers
TDA.Reeb.ThickeningWindow defines the pieces of the thickening presentation. For a height c,
write J(c) = [max a (c - ε), min d (c + ε)] for the slice of a segment [a, d]
(Thickening.slice); for a vertex strip [a i, a i] it is {a i} or empty.
- Window. The raw window at
cisΣ V i × J_i(c) ⊕ Σ E e × J_e(c), withJ_i(c) = slice (a i) (a i) ε candJ_e(c) = slice (a e) (a (e+1)) ε c. The windowP.Window S ε cis its quotient by "same point ofX", with the quotient topology. SowindowMkis a quotient map by definition, also after product with a locally compact space (isQuotientMap_prodMap_windowMk), and two raw window points are identified exactly when their normal forms inPagree (windowMk_eq_iff).windowToSpaceis a continuous injection intoXwith height in[c - ε, c + ε]. The window is compact, resp. locally path-connected, when all pieces are, as a quotient of a finite sum of products of pieces with compact intervals; it is empty when all pieces are. That the window is homeomorphic to the subspacef⁻¹[c - ε, c + ε]ofXis not claimed; without a Hausdorff hypothesis, the quotient topology is the one used. - Transfer. Under
RGraph.TransferOK S ε c u, every slice parameter moves by the affine fragment mapRGraph.fragAffof its segment (rawTransfer); vertex parameters stay ata i. Slice ends at segment ends stay there, so glued points stay glued and the map descends to the continuoustransfer : Window c → Window u(windowMk_rawTransfer_eq). InXit fixes vertex points and moves an edge point at parameterσtofragAff … c u σ(windowToSpace_transfer_inl,windowToSpace_transfer_inr). At a slab end with a point slice it collapses a whole edge slice, so it need not be injective. Along a locally compact setUof target heights the transfers form one jointly continuous maptransferFamily : Window c × U → X, descended alongwindowMk × id_U. - Interior inverse. With transfer hypotheses in both directions, for instance two heights of one
open slab of a grid listing the shifted levels, the transfers are mutually inverse
(
transfer_transfer,transferHomeomorph). This holds for everyε ≥ 0: at a point slice the affine map is the constant lower end, by Lean's division by zero.
Fixtures (TDA.Reeb.ThickeningWindowExamples): for the single segment at ε = 1/4, the transfer
of the window at 0 to the slab end -1/4 identifies two distinct edge points; at ε = 0 the
transfer between 1/2 and 1/4 is a homeomorphism; a window of the presentation whose pieces are
the Sierpiński space is compact and locally path-connected but not Hausdorff; windows far from the
levels, and all windows of the presentation with empty pieces, are empty.
The general presentation
TDA.Reeb.ThickeningPresentation builds the thickening presentation P_ε of a cylinder
presentation P over levels S and proves that it realizes the thickening. Write
X = P.Realization S, f = P.height S, and let G be any grid listing every shifted level
S.value i ± ε (S.ContainsShifted ε G).
- Presentation.
P.thick S ε G hGhas vertex piecejthe window at the levelb jand edge piecekthe window at the midpoint of slabk; the endpoint maps are the window transfers to the two slab ends. Its pieces are compact, resp. locally path-connected, when all pieces ofPare: they are quotients of finite sums of compact (locally path-connected) spaces. Pieces are empty where no piece ofPreaches, and coincident shifted values are single levels ofG. On the shifted witnessS.shifted ε, whose levels are the distinct values of(S - ε) ∪ (S + ε), it isshiftedThick. - Comparison.
toProd : |P_ε| → X × [-ε, ε]is the universal map sending a vertex pointξof levelb jto(ξ, b j - f ξ)and a cylinder point(ξ, u)to(transfer ξ, u - f (transfer ξ)), through the band{(x, u) | u - ε ≤ f x ≤ u + ε}(toBand,slabCylinder) andGeometricThickening.bandHomeomorph. It carries the height ofP_εtof x + t(height_toProd). - Attachment maps. The per-piece thickening presentations of the one-cylinder construction, built
directly on the common grid
G, map intoP_εby presentation morphisms:edgeIncl efromcylinderThick (a e) (a (e+1)) ε (E e) GandvertexIncl ifromcylinderThick (a i) (a i) ε (V i) G, each sending a slice point to its window class. After the per-piece homeomorphisms they are(y, s, t) ↦ ([y, s], t)and(v, t) ↦ ([v], t)(toProd_realize_edgeIncl,toProd_realize_vertexIncl). - Inverse.
rawInvon the thickened raw piecesΣ V i × [-ε, ε] ⊕ Σ E e × [a e, a (e+1)] × [-ε, ε]pushes the inverses of the per-piece homeomorphisms intoP_εbyHom.realize. At a point of height a level it is a vertex point, over an open slab a cylinder point (rawInv_windowBand_value,rawInv_windowBand_of_mem_K). It respects the endpoint identifications ofP(rawInv_segBot,rawInv_segTop): both sides are window points with the same image inX. So it depends only on normal forms (rawInv_nf) and descends along the quotient mapquotMk × id(isQuotientMap_rawBandMap) to the continuousofProd : X × [-ε, ε] → |P_ε|. - Homeomorphism. Both inverse laws are checked on generators with the universal property
(
toProd_ofProd,ofProd_toProd), sothickHomeomorph : |P_ε| ≃ₜ X × [-ε, ε]is a height-preserving homeomorphism (height_thickHomeomorph), with the inverse at generatorsthickHomeomorph_symm_quotMk,thickHomeomorph_symm_windowToSpace_valueandthickHomeomorph_symm_windowToSpace_of_mem_K. It holds for pieces that are arbitrary topological spaces, everyε ≥ 0and every such grid; no separation, compactness or positivity hypothesis is used, and continuity of the inverse comes from the quotient map, not from a compact-to-Hausdorff argument. The shifted-witness instance isshiftedThickHomeomorph.
Correspondence with the plan of Issue #708. Steps 1–3 (the vertex/cylinder/endpoint attachment
diagram, its product with the band, and the per-piece thickenings) are the thickened raw pieces,
isQuotientMap_rawBandMap, cylinderThick and cylinderThickHomeomorph. Steps 4–6 (refinement
to the common grid, the componentwise colimit and the fixed-grid comparison) are realized as
follows: the per-piece presentations are built directly on the common grid G, so empty pieces
appear automatically and no refinement operation is defined; the attachment maps are the
morphisms edgeIncl e and vertexIncl i into P_ε; and the colimit comparison is the descent
of rawInv along quotMk × id, which exhibits X × [-ε, ε] as the quotient of the thickened
pieces by the endpoint identifications. Agreement of the original endpoint relations with the
refined attaching maps is rawInv_segBot, rawInv_segTop together with
toProd_realize_edgeIncl and toProd_realize_vertexIncl. Only this fixed-grid,
cylinder-compatible attachment diagram is covered, not arbitrary finite colimits of constructible
ℝ-spaces. IsConstructibleSpace is unchanged; the constructibility consequence is assembled in
TDA.Reeb.ThickeningConstructible (next section).
Fixtures (TDA.Reeb.ThickeningPresentationExamples), each applying the homeomorphism: one point
at one level with no edges; the presentation with empty pieces, whose thickening presentation is
empty, and a grid with an extra far level whose vertex piece is empty; the segment over pair 0 1
at ε = 1/2, whose shifted values 0 + ε = 1 - ε merge; ε = 0 on the grid S01, where a
cylinder point at height u goes to the parameter u; and the Sierpiński presentation, whose
thickening presentation has compact locally path-connected pieces and a non-Hausdorff
realization.
Theorem 4.27
TDA.Reeb.ThickeningConstructible assembles the constructibility of thickenings from the general
presentation, with no further geometric argument.
- Over
ℝ. For a presentationPover levelsS,thickOverIsois the isomorphism overℝfrom the thickening of the realization (GeometricThickening.functor εapplied toOver.mk (P.height S)) to the realization ofP.shiftedThick S εover the shifted witnessS.shifted ε. Its underlying map is the inverse ofshiftedThickHomeomorph(thickOverIso_hom_left_apply), and its height equation isheight_thickHomeomorph_symm. No hypothesis on the pieces is used. ForA ≅ |P|overℝ,thickOverIsoOfIsocomposes the thickening of that isomorphism withthickOverIso. - Presentation level. If the pieces of
Pare compact and locally path-connected, so are the windows ofP.shiftedThick S ε, and the thickening of|P|is constructible, presented onS.shifted ε(isConstructibleSpace_thickening_realization). - General form.
isConstructibleSpace_thickening_of_isConstructibleSpace: for everyA : Over (TopCat.of ℝ)withIsConstructibleSpace Aand everyε : ℝ≥0, the thickening(GeometricThickening.functor ε).obj Ais constructible. The proof takes the presentation and the isomorphismA ≅ |P|supplied byIsConstructibleSpaceand appliesthickOverIsoOfIso. There is no Hausdorff hypothesis onAor on the pieces, no positivity hypothesis onε, andIsConstructibleSpaceis unchanged. The name is chosen to differ from the graph statementRGraph.isConstructibleSpace_thickening. - Critical set. If
Ais presented overS, its thickening is presented overS.shifted ε, whose levels are the distinct values of(S - ε) ∪ (S + ε)in increasing order (CriticalValues.mem_range_shifted_iff). This is an admissible critical set for the thickened height, not necessarily the minimal one; no candidate value is asserted to be essential. - Fibers. The vertex piece of
P.shiftedThick S εat a shifted levelb j, the window atb j, is homeomorphic to the fiber of the thickened height overb jbyξ ↦ (ξ, b j - f ξ)(windowFiberHomeomorph,coe_windowFiberHomeomorph), throughcriticalFiberHomeomorphof the thickening presentation and the homeomorphism. It is derived from the homeomorphism and is not used in the construction, which uses only the quotient topology of the window. - Functor.
thickeningFunctor ε : ConstructibleSpaceCat ⥤ ConstructibleSpaceCatliftsGeometricThickening.functor εon all height-preserving maps (thickeningFunctor_comp_ι). Its comparison with the smoothing of constructible cosheaves (Theorem 4.24 restricted to constructible ℝ-spaces) and the companion for the Reeb quotient of the thickening are inreeb-thickening-cosheaf-comparison.md. - Graph input.
isConstructibleSpace_thickening_of_isRGraphderives the graph statement from the general one throughisConstructibleSpace_of_isRGraph. On graph objects the lift is the graph lift:RGraph.rgraphToConstructible ⋙ thickeningFunctor ε = RGraph.thickeningToConstructible ε(rgraphToConstructible_comp_thickeningFunctor). The existing graph results and their proof (seereeb-rgraph-thickening.md) are unchanged; the general route presents a graph thickening by windows, which are compact and locally path-connected but not finite discrete, also atε = 0. - Reeb quotient. Followed by the Reeb quotient, the lift is the existing
RGraph.thickeningQuotient ε(thickeningFunctor_comp_quotientRGraphFunctor). The statement thatℛ T_ε Xis a graph object (isRGraph_quotient_thickening_of_isConstructibleSpace, seereeb-quotient-thickening-absorption.md) remains a distinct statement with its own proof; the equation only identifies the two functors.
Fixtures (TDA.Reeb.ThickeningConstructibleExamples): a compact locally path-connected space at
constant height c is constructible, and so is its thickening, with shifted levels c - ε and
c + ε; the indiscrete two-point space at constant height is constructible, its thickening is
constructible, and neither the thickened space nor any vertex piece of its thickening
presentation is Hausdorff, so the theorem does not specialize to Hausdorff inputs; ε = 0 by the
general theorem and, independently, through zeroIso; the empty space, whose thickening is
constructible and empty; and S = {0, 2} at ε = 1, whose four shifted values merge to three
levels (shiftedCount = 2), with the theorem applied to the segment over S.
Source correspondence
de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §2.2, define constructible ℝ-spaces as
realizations of compact locally path-connected pieces, and Theorem 4.27 states that the thickening
of a constructible ℝ-space is constructible; its proof builds the thickening from the windows
and fibers of the input. With IsConstructibleSpace for the source's ℝ-Topᶜ, Theorem 4.27
is claimed here in general form: isConstructibleSpace_thickening_of_isConstructibleSpace, for every
constructible ℝ-space and every ε ≥ 0, with pieces that need not be Hausdorff. The critical set
of the proof, (S - ε) ∪ (S + ε) in increasing order, is S.shifted ε; it is used as an
admissible critical set. Corollary 4.28 states that f_ε has critical set (S - ε) ∪ (S + ε)
when f has critical set S; in the sense of a set over which the thickening is presented,
this is isConstructibleSpace_thickening_of_isConstructibleSpace, through thickOverIsoOfIso, and
on a presentation isConstructibleSpace_thickening_realization. Minimality, that
every value of S.shifted ε is essential for f_ε, is not claimed. The tools, the one-cylinder
presentation and the general presentation above are library statements on which the theorem
rests. The source's proof ends
with a fiberwise bijection and the compact-to-Hausdorff theorem; for non-Hausdorff pieces the
inverse is instead shown continuous by the quotient-topology comparison of the general
presentation. This records a different proof route for the library's broader class, not an error
in the source. Graph input (Proposition 4.26) is a specialization
(isConstructibleSpace_thickening_of_isRGraph; see reeb-rgraph-thickening.md for the graph
case formalized earlier), and the Reeb-quotient statement of
reeb-quotient-thickening-absorption.md remains distinct.
The statements of Theorem 4.27 and Corollary 4.28 and the steps of the proof of Theorem 4.27 were compared with the HTML version of arXiv:1501.04147v1.
Source: de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §2.2 and §4.3, Theorem 4.27 and Corollary 4.28.