The thickening–cosheaf comparison on constructible ℝ-spaces

Setting

ConstructibleSpaceCat is the full subcategory of constructible ℝ-spaces of the real slice Over (TopCat.of ℝ), with all continuous height-preserving maps (see reeb-constructible-quotient.md). IsConstructibleSpace asks for an isomorphism over ℝ with the realization of a presentation whose pieces are compact and locally path-connected; no piece and no realization is assumed Hausdorff, and every presentation has at least one critical level, also for the empty space.

  • T_ε = thickeningFunctor ε : ConstructibleSpaceCat ⥤ ConstructibleSpaceCat is the product thickening X × [-ε, ε] with height (x, t) ↦ f x + t and maps (x, t) ↦ (g x, t), for every ε : ℝ≥0 (see reeb-thickening-constructible.md).
  • C' = constructibleCosheafFunctor : ConstructibleSpaceCat ⥤ ConstructibleCosheafCat.{0} sends X to the path components of the inverse images of open intervals (see reeb-constructible-comparison.md).
  • S_ε = constructibleSmoothing ε : ConstructibleCosheafCat.{0} ⥤ ConstructibleCosheafCat.{0} is the smoothing F ↦ F ∘ (·)^ε of constructible cosheaves (see reeb-constructible-smoothing.md). It is not RGraph.constructibleSmoothing ε, the endofunctor ℛ T_ε of constructible ℝ-spaces of reeb-geometric-interleaving-equivalence.md.
  • ℛ = quotientRGraphFunctor : ConstructibleSpaceCat ⥤ RGraphCat is the Reeb functor and C'' = RGraph.cosheafFunctor : RGraphCat ⥤ ConstructibleCosheafCat.{0} the path-component cosheaf of a graph object (see reeb-rgraph-cosheaf-equivalence.md).
  • η = constructibleCosheafComparisonIso : C' ≅ ℛ ⋙ C'' is the comparison of the path components of a constructible ℝ-space with those of its Reeb quotient (see reeb-constructible-comparison.md).
  • ρ = GeometricThickening.componentComparisonNatIso ε is the first-projection comparison T_ε ⋙ C ≅ C ⋙ smoothing ε on the whole real slice; on an interval I it sends the class of (x, t) in {z | f x + t ∈ I} to the class of x in {x | f x ∈ I^ε} (see reeb-geometric-thickening.md).

Everything is in universe 0, as ConstructibleSpaceCat and ConstructibleCosheafCat.{0} are. No new geometric argument is made: the results lift ρ through the full subcategories and compose it with η⁻¹.

The comparison

constructibleThickeningComparisonIso ε :
    thickeningFunctor ε ⋙ constructibleCosheafFunctor ≅
      constructibleCosheafFunctor ⋙ constructibleSmoothing ε

has the components of ρ (constructibleThickeningComparisonIso_hom_app_hom, constructibleThickeningComparisonIso_inv_app_hom, and unbundled as GeometricThickening.componentComparison of the structure map, constructibleThickeningComparisonIso_hom_app_hom_eq, all by rfl). On representatives (constructibleThickeningComparisonIso_hom_app_hom_app_mk), for every open interval I and every (x, t) with f x + t ∈ I,

ρ_X(I) [(x, t)] = [x]   in the components of {x | f x ∈ I^ε}.

Both inverse laws are those of an isomorphism in ConstructibleCosheafCat.{0}, so they hold for the whole interval functors, and naturality is the naturality of ρ in slice morphisms: it holds for every continuous height-preserving map, whatever presentations, critical lists or numbers of levels its source and target have. Followed by the inclusion of constructible cosheaves it is ρ whiskered by the inclusion of constructible ℝ-spaces (isoWhiskerRight_constructibleThickeningComparisonIso).

The companion

constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso ε :
    thickeningFunctor ε ⋙ quotientRGraphFunctor ⋙ RGraph.cosheafFunctor ≅
      constructibleCosheafFunctor ⋙ constructibleSmoothing ε :=
  Functor.isoWhiskerLeft (thickeningFunctor ε) constructibleCosheafComparisonIso.symm ≪≫
    constructibleThickeningComparisonIso ε

Its source is also RGraph.thickeningQuotient ε ⋙ RGraph.cosheafFunctor (thickeningFunctor_comp_quotientRGraphFunctor_comp_cosheafFunctor, by rfl). The component at X is β_X = η_(T_ε X).inv ≫ ρ_X, in the full subcategory and on the underlying precosheaves (constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app, constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app_hom), with inverse ρ_X⁻¹ ≫ η_(T_ε X) (constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_inv_app). Naturality is that of the composite of two natural isomorphisms, again for all height-preserving maps.

The canonical hom-component equation η_(T_ε X).hom ≫ β_X = ρ_X holds in the full subcategory (constructibleCosheafComparisonIso_hom_app_comp_constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app) and unbundled, with ReebQuotient.intervalComponentComparison of the thickened height and GeometricThickening.componentComparison (intervalComponentComparison_comp_constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app_hom). On representatives (constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app_hom_app_mk),

β_X(I) [q (x, t)] = [x],

where q is the Reeb projection of T_ε X, the left class lies in the components of {p | q̄ p ∈ I} of the Reeb quotient and the right class in the components of {x | f x ∈ I^ε}. This is a statement about components; no map from points of the Reeb quotient to X is asserted.

Zero section and unit

thickeningFunctorZeroSection ε : 𝟭 ConstructibleSpaceCat ⟶ thickeningFunctor ε is the zero section x ↦ (x, 0) of GeometricThickening.zeroSectionNatTrans ε, lifted (thickeningFunctorZeroSection_app_hom). The comparison sends C' of it to the lifted smoothing unit:

constructibleCosheafFunctor.map ((thickeningFunctorZeroSection ε).app A) ≫
    (constructibleThickeningComparisonIso ε).hom.app A =
  (constructibleSmoothingUnit ε).app (constructibleCosheafFunctor.obj A)

(constructibleCosheafFunctor_map_thickeningFunctorZeroSection_comp), and as an equation of natural transformations C' ⟶ C' ⋙ S_ε (whiskerRight_thickeningFunctorZeroSection_comp_constructibleThickeningComparisonIso). Both are GeometricThickening.map_zeroSectionNatTrans_comp_componentComparisonNatIso.

For the companion, the unit is the existing RGraph.constructibleSmoothingUnit ε : X ⟶ ℛ T_ε X, the zero section followed by the Reeb projection (see reeb-geometric-interleaving-equivalence.md); no new structure is introduced. Then

constructibleCosheafFunctor.map ((RGraph.constructibleSmoothingUnit ε).app A) ≫
    (constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso ε).hom.app A =
  (constructibleSmoothingUnit ε).app (constructibleCosheafFunctor.obj A)

(constructibleCosheafFunctor_map_constructibleSmoothingUnit_comp): C' of the Reeb projection of T_ε X is η_(T_ε X).hom, which cancels against η_(T_ε X).inv in β_X, and the zero-section equation remains. On representatives, [x] ↦ [q (x, 0)] ↦ [x] (constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app_hom_app_unit_mk).

ε = 0

thickeningFunctorZeroIso : thickeningFunctor 0 ≅ 𝟭 ConstructibleSpaceCat lifts GeometricThickening.zeroIso, the first projection X × [0, 0] → X (thickeningFunctorZeroIso_hom_app_hom, thickeningFunctorZeroIso_inv_app_hom); its inverse is the zero section (thickeningFunctorZeroIso_inv). At ε = 0,

constructibleCosheafFunctor.map (thickeningFunctorZeroIso.hom.app A) =
  (constructibleThickeningComparisonIso 0).hom.app A ≫
    constructibleSmoothingZeroIso.hom.app (constructibleCosheafFunctor.obj A)

(constructibleCosheafFunctor_map_thickeningFunctorZeroIso_hom_app, from GeometricThickening.map_zeroIso_hom_app). On a constructible ℝ-space the Reeb quotient of T_0 X is the Reeb quotient of X, not X, so the companion's zero comparison passes through η_X:

RGraph.cosheafFunctor.map (quotientRGraphFunctor.map (thickeningFunctorZeroIso.hom.app A)) ≫
    constructibleCosheafComparisonIso.inv.app A =
  (constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso 0).hom.app A ≫
    constructibleSmoothingZeroIso.hom.app (constructibleCosheafFunctor.obj A)

(cosheafFunctor_map_thickeningFunctorZeroIso_comp_constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso), by naturality of η⁻¹ along T_0 X ≅ X.

Graph objects

On graph objects RGraph.rgraphToConstructible ⋙ thickeningFunctor ε is RGraph.thickeningToConstructible ε (see reeb-thickening-constructible.md). Along this inclusion

  • the comparison is the graph comparison RGraph.thickeningCosheafComparisonIso ε (isoWhiskerLeft_rgraphToConstructible_constructibleThickeningComparisonIso, and componentwise constructibleThickeningComparisonIso_hom_app_rgraphToConstructible);
  • the companion is RGraph.geometricSmoothingComparisonIso ε, DMP Proposition 4.32 (isoWhiskerLeft_rgraphToConstructible_constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso, and componentwise constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso_hom_app_rgraphToConstructible).

Both equations hold by rfl on components; see reeb-rgraph-smoothing.md for the graph results, which are unchanged.

Values

constructibleThickeningValueEquiv ε X I : C'(T_ε X)(I) ≃ C'(X)(I^ε) and constructibleThickeningQuotientValueEquiv ε X I : C''(ℛ T_ε X)(I) ≃ C'(X)(I^ε) are the comparison and the companion at one interval (constructibleThickeningValueEquiv_apply, constructibleThickeningQuotientValueEquiv_apply).

Fixtures

TDA.Reeb.ThickeningCosheafComparisonExamples reuses the constant-height spaces constOver X c, the indiscrete two-point space IndiscreteBool and the non-Hausdorff thickening of reeb-thickening-constructible.md, and the single edge over 0 < 1, its subdivision over 0 < 1/2 < 1 and the subdivision isomorphism of reeb-rgraph-cosheaf-equivalence.md.

  • Empty input. For the empty space at constant height, every value of C'(T_ε X) and of C''(ℛ T_ε X) is empty, for every ε (thickening_empty_isEmpty, thickeningQuotient_empty_isEmpty), transported through the value equivalences from the empty values of C'(X).
  • A non-Hausdorff constant-height input. For the indiscrete two-point space at height c, every map into a subspace is continuous, so any two points of an inverse image are joined (joined_indiscreteBool) and every value of C'(X) has at most one element. Through the comparison and the companion, every value of C'(T_ε X) and of C''(ℛ T_ε X) has at most one element, while T_ε X is not Hausdorff (indiscrete_thickening_subsingleton, indiscrete_thickeningQuotient_subsingleton); the value at I is nonempty when c ∈ I^ε (indiscrete_thickening_nonempty). For band coordinates s, t with c + s, c + t ∈ I, the classes of (true, s) and (false, t) agree, as do those of their Reeb classes, and both comparisons send them to [true] (indiscrete_thickening_class_eq, indiscrete_thickeningQuotient_class_eq).
  • ε = 0. The zero comparisons of the comparison and the companion on the indiscrete two-point space (indiscrete_zero_comparison, indiscrete_zero_companion), and, for every constructible ℝ-space, the value of C'(T_0 X) at I corresponds to the value of C'(X) at I through thicken_zero (zeroValueEquiv).
  • Naturality for a nontrivial map across presentations. collapse sends the indiscrete two-point space at height 0, presented over the one level 0, to the lower vertex of the single edge, presented over 0 < 1; it identifies the two points (collapse_not_injective). The comparison and the companion are natural along it (collapse_naturality, collapse_companion_naturality). Along the subdivision isomorphism from the single edge over 0 < 1/2 < 1 to the single edge over 0 < 1, the companion's naturality square is, as a term, the graph square RGraphSmoothing.subdivision_naturality (subdivision_companion_naturality).

Source correspondence

de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §3.4 and §4.3–4.4:

  • Theorem 4.24 states 𝒞T_ε ≅ S_ε𝒞 for ℝ-spaces, with the comparison (ρ_f)_I = π₀[p_I] of its proof; on the real slice this is GeometricThickening.componentComparisonNatIso (see reeb-geometric-thickening.md). Restricted to constructible ℝ-spaces, where T_ε preserves constructibility by Theorem 4.27 (see reeb-thickening-constructible.md) and 𝒞 restricts to 𝒞', it reads 𝒞'T_ε ≅ S_ε𝒞' as functors ℝ-Topᶜ → Cshᶜ; this restriction is constructibleThickeningComparisonIso. It is the source's theorem on a full subcategory, not a separately numbered statement of the source.
  • Theorem 3.17 states 𝒞' ≅ 𝒞''ℛ on ℝ-Topᶜ; this is constructibleCosheafComparisonIso (see reeb-constructible-comparison.md).
  • Proposition 4.32 states 𝒞''U_ε ≅ S_ε𝒞'' on Reeb, proved by 𝒞''ℛT_ε ≃ 𝒞'T_ε ≃ S_ε𝒞'' with Theorems 3.17 and 4.24. It is already proved on graph objects as RGraph.geometricSmoothingComparisonIso (see reeb-rgraph-smoothing.md). The companion constructibleThickeningQuotientComparisonIso is the same composite, η⁻¹ at the thickening followed by the restricted Theorem 4.24, on all constructible ℝ-spaces, with 𝒞' in place of 𝒞'' on the right. It is a library statement extending the proof of Proposition 4.32 to constructible input, not attributed to the source as a numbered result; the source states Proposition 4.32 only for ℝ-graphs, where its target S_ε𝒞'' is S_ε𝒞' of the inclusion and the companion restricts to RGraph.geometricSmoothingComparisonIso.
  • Observation 4.23 gives the zero section τ^ε : X → X_ε, x ↦ (x, 0), natural on all ℝ-spaces; thickeningFunctorZeroSection is its restriction to constructible ℝ-spaces, and 𝒞'(τ^ε) followed by the restricted Theorem 4.24 is the smoothing unit.
  • Observation 4.34 and Proposition 4.35 give the unit ζ as the zero section followed by the Reeb quotient and state its compatibility with σ through the isomorphism of Proposition 4.32, for ℝ-graphs. The companion's unit equation uses the same zero section followed by the Reeb projection, RGraph.constructibleSmoothingUnit, on constructible ℝ-spaces, in the form 𝒞'(ζ) ≫ β = σ; it is proved by exact cancellation of η, as on graph objects, and is a library statement on constructible input.

No new geometric argument, critical-set statement or reproof of the constructibility of T_ε X is made. Not claimed here: T_ε T_δ ≅ T_(ε+δ) for product thickening (false in general, see reeb-geometric-thickening-addition.md); an exact or minimal critical set for T_ε X, beyond the admissible shifted set of reeb-thickening-constructible.md; any new interleaving distance; ordered-space or Reeb-ordering results; universes other than 0.

The statements of Theorems 3.17 and 4.24, Observation 4.23, Proposition 4.32, Observation 4.34 and Proposition 4.35 used here are those recorded, with their comparison against the HTML version of arXiv:1501.04147v1, in reeb-constructible-comparison.md, reeb-geometric-thickening.md and reeb-rgraph-smoothing.md.

Source: de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §3.4, Theorem 3.17, §4.3, Observation 4.23, Theorems 4.24 and 4.27, and §4.4, Proposition 4.32, Observation 4.34 and Proposition 4.35.