The thickening addition map
Setting
This digest continues reeb-geometric-thickening.md and uses its thickening without
redefinition. For ε : ℝ≥0, Band ε = [-ε, ε], the thickening of (X, f) is X × Band ε with
height height f ε (x, t) = f x + t, map g ε (x, t) = (g x, t), and functor ε is the
thickening on the real slice Over (TopCat.of ℝ). The cosheaf side is the smoothing of
reeb-smoothing.md, with its composition isomorphism
smoothingCompIso ε δ : smoothing δ ⋙ smoothing ε ≅ smoothing (ε + δ).
For product thickening, T_ε T_δ ≅ T_(ε+δ) is false. Over a point at height 0 with
ε = δ = 1, the height-0 fibre of T_1 T_1 is the segment {((*, s), -s)}, while that of
T_2 is the single point (*, 0). The correct statement is a height-preserving addition map with
lax coherence.
The addition map
addMap X ε δ : C((X × Band δ) × Band ε, X × Band (ε + δ)), ((x, s), t) ↦ (x, s + t)
The outer parameter comes first: the source is T_ε (T_δ X), matching smoothingCompIso ε δ and
smoothing δ ⋙ smoothing ε. The band coordinate lies in Band (ε + δ) because |s| ≤ δ and
|t| ≤ ε (add_mem_band). The parameter ε + δ is never rewritten to δ + ε. Equalities of
parameters are bridged by bandInclusion, never by casts on Band.
The laws, each an equation of continuous maps proved on coordinates:
- Height.
height f (ε + δ) (addMap X ε δ z) = height (height f δ) ε z, that isf x + (s + t) = (f x + s) + t(height_addMap). - Naturality in every continuous
g, with no height hypothesis (addMap_natural). - Band enlargement in both parameters,
ε ≤ ε'andδ ≤ δ'(addMap_comp_bandInclusion). - Associativity on
((X × Band γ) × Band δ) × Band ε, the two composites agree after(ε + δ) + γ ≤ ε + (δ + γ)(addMap_assoc). - Units. After
0 + δ ≤ δ,μ_(0,δ)iszeroHomeomorph; afterδ + 0 ≤ δ,μ_(δ,0)isT_δofzeroHomeomorph(addMap_zero_left,addMap_zero_right). - Zero sections.
μ_(ε,δ)after the outer zero section is the enlargementδ ≤ ε + δ, and afterT_εof the inner zero section it is the enlargementε ≤ ε + δ(addMap_comp_zeroSection,addMap_comp_map_zeroSection).
The addition map is surjective: (x, u) is the image of ((x, s), u - s) with s the projection
of u onto [-δ, δ], and |u| ≤ ε + δ puts u - s in [-ε, ε] (addMap_surjective). For
nonempty X and ε, δ > 0 it is not injective: with m = min ε δ > 0, the points ((x, 0), 0)
and ((x, m), -m) differ and have the same image (addMap_not_injective).
The real slice
bandInclusionNatTrans (h : ε ≤ δ) : functor ε ⟶ functor δ
addNatTrans ε δ : functor δ ⋙ functor ε ⟶ functor (ε + δ)
The components are bandInclusion and addMap of the underlying space, by rfl
(bandInclusionNatTrans_app_left_hom, addNatTrans_app_left_hom). The laws above hold as
equations of natural transformations, with the associator and unitors definitional:
- associativity,
whiskerLeft (functor γ) (addNatTrans ε δ) ≫ addNatTrans (ε + δ) γ ≫ bandInclusionNatTrans _ = whiskerRight (addNatTrans δ γ) (functor ε) ≫ addNatTrans ε (δ + γ)(addNatTrans_assoc); - units against
zeroIso,addNatTrans 0 δ ≫ bandInclusionNatTrans _ = whiskerLeft (functor δ) zeroIso.homandaddNatTrans δ 0 ≫ bandInclusionNatTrans _ = whiskerRight zeroIso.hom (functor δ)(addNatTrans_zero_left,addNatTrans_zero_right); - zero sections,
whiskerLeft (functor δ) (zeroSectionNatTrans ε) ≫ addNatTrans ε δandwhiskerRight (zeroSectionNatTrans δ) (functor ε) ≫ addNatTrans ε δare the enlargementsδ ≤ ε + δandε ≤ ε + δ; - band enlargement in both parameters (
addNatTrans_comp_bandInclusionNatTrans).
So (functor, zeroSectionNatTrans, addNatTrans) is a lax composition law over the additive
monoid ℝ≥0, with unit and associativity holding up to band enlargement.
Path components
With ρ_ε = componentComparison f ε : C(T_ε f) ⟶ S_ε C(f),
intervalComponentNatTrans (addMap X ε δ) _ ≫ componentComparison f (ε + δ) =
componentComparison (height f δ) ε ≫ (smoothing ε).map (componentComparison f δ) ≫
(smoothingCompIso ε δ).hom.app (intervalComponents f)
(addMap_comp_componentComparison). On a representative ((x, s), t) both sides give the class of
x in f ⁻¹ (thicken (ε + δ) I): the left side through (x, s + t), the right side through
(x, s), then x in f ⁻¹ (thicken δ (thicken ε I)), then the transport of
thickenCompIso ε δ, which is the identity on points. The equation uses the smoothingCompIso. On the slice it holds objectwise
(map_addNatTrans_comp_componentComparisonNatIso) and as an equation of natural transformations
(functor δ ⋙ functor ε) ⋙ 𝒞 ⟶ 𝒞 ⋙ smoothing (ε + δ)
(whiskerRight_addNatTrans_comp_componentComparisonNatIso).
Since every other factor is an isomorphism, π₀ of the addition map is an isomorphism
(isIso_intervalComponentNatTrans_addMap, isIso_map_addNatTrans_app), bijective at every
interval (intervalComponentNatTrans_addMap_app_bijective), although the addition map is not a
homeomorphism.
The one-point counterexample
onePoint is PUnit over height 0. The map fiberSegment : s ↦ ((*, s), -s) from Band 1 to
T_1 T_1 of the point is injective and lands at height 0 (fiber_zero_injective). Every
height-0 fibre of T_ε of the point is a subsingleton, since 0 + t = 0 forces t = 0
(fiber_zero_subsingleton). A slice isomorphism is injective and preserves height, so it would
send fiberSegment 0 and fiberSegment 1 to one point. Hence
not_iso_one_one : IsEmpty ((functor 1).obj ((functor 1).obj onePoint) ≅ (functor (1 + 1)).obj onePoint)
and (addNatTrans 1 1).app onePoint is not an isomorphism (not_isIso_addNatTrans_app_one_one).
The proof compares fibres; non-injectivity of μ alone would not exclude other isomorphisms.
Fixtures
TDA.Reeb.GeometricThickeningAdditionExamples:
- One point. The non-isomorphism, the explicit pair
((*, 0), 0) ≠ ((*, 1), -1)with one image underμ_(1,1), the boundary point(*, 2)as the image of((*, 1), 1), and bijectiveπ₀ofμ_(1,1)atℝon the same object. - Boundary control. On the point,
μ_(0,δ)andμ_(ε,0)are injective by the unit laws, so non-injectivity needs both parameters positive. - One edge. On the realization of
singleEdgeover0 < 1, both sides ofheight_addMapat((q, 1/4), 1/4)withqat height1/2are1, and associativity atε = δ = γ = 1/4gives band coordinate3/4. - Two merging edges. On
parallelData, the naturality squares ofaddMapandaddNatTransfor the edge swap send the point over edgetrueat thickened height1/2to the point over edgefalse, which differs from it. The collapse onto the single edge is checked the same way; its one-class target alone could not detect a wrong map. - Distinct classes. On the two disjoint segments,
π₀ofμ_(1,1)atℝsends the classes over the labelsfalseandtrueto classes separated bytwoSegLabelof the first coordinate.
Source correspondence
de Silva, Munch and Patel, Categorified Reeb Graphs, §4.3 Definition 4.22, supplies the
thickening X_ε = X × [-ε, ε], f_ε(x, t) = f(x) + t and T_ε[α] used here. Its Proposition
4.16, the cosheaf-side composition law, is the merged smoothingCompIso. §4.4 Observation
4.33 asserts semigroup isomorphisms U_(ε₁+ε₂) ≃ U_(ε₁) U_(ε₂) for the Reeb smoothing
U_ε = ℛ T_ε.
The addition map, its coherence laws, the π₀ compatibility and the one-point non-isomorphism are
library statements; none is attributed to the source.
Not claimed here: the Reeb quotient comparison ℛ T_ε T_δ ≅ ℛ T_(ε+δ), which is proved in
reeb-quotient-thickening-addition.md; the absorption
ℛ T_ε ℛ ≅ ℛ T_ε; the semigroup isomorphisms of Observation 4.33 for geometric smoothing; the
geometric interleavings of Definition 4.36 and any distance inequality; a first projection or any
other non-height-preserving map packaged as a slice morphism. The one-point witness shows that the
analogue of Observation 4.33 for T itself fails.